I made $16 on my first day in sales. $10.25 after the train.
I was standing on a milk crate outside Fenway Park yelling “programs, get your programs here” for three hours in the sun. I lost my voice. A scalper told me the corner of Lansdowne had been his for ten years and I had no business being there. I thought about quitting.
Instead, on my day off, I went back and watched the best seller on the crew. He didn’t yell. He didn’t stand on a crate. He walked up to families in a calm voice and asked if they wanted a souvenir. The kids would look up at their parents, and any parent knows what happens next. He didn’t have the most transactions – he had the biggest ones. So I copied him. By the end of the summer I was a regular top-three seller, and I’d figured out that I loved sales because of the strategy and care that goes into it, not the yelling.
Nobody at Williams told me that was a career. When I walked into the career center as a psychology major, the menu was consulting, banking, or grad school. I didn’t want crazy hours. The most useful thing I found in that building was an email template buried in the alumni database with the subject line “Williams student seeking advice.” I sent a lot of those.
I fumbled my first three SDR interviews. On the mock cold call I pitched the product instead of the pain. For the mock email I googled “cold email tips” and wrote something so full of jargon that when I reread it months later it didn’t make sense. In the manager interview I talked the whole time about how great I’d be. After each rejection I asked for feedback, actually implemented it, and started preparing the way I’d been taught to prepare for a tutorial: two hours on the company, the interviewer, and the reps who already had the job. I got offers from three of my next five.
I was still scared. I had a psychology degree and no “real” experience. I was deathly afraid of cold calling for my first few weeks. The imposter syndrome didn’t leave when the results showed up. I hit 325% of quota my first month and set the team record for qualified leads in month two, and there were still weeks I felt like I was dialing into a black hole. When I got promoted to AE I was 3-14 on deals six months in. The reps who make it aren’t the ones who never feel doubt. They’re the ones who feel it and show up anyway.
What got me through was people. A Williams alum told me to read Fanatical Prospecting before day one. A seller named Jeff, whose “authentic selling” ideas turned my 3-14 into 14-3. Brian, my manager at Brazen, who answered every dumb question. Engineers who explained our product to me four different ways until I could explain it to a customer. My standing advice to anyone joining a startup is to get to know each person on the team individually before you sign, because you’re about to spend more waking hours with them than with anyone else in your life.
A couple of years ago, on vacation alone in Portugal, our founders asked if I’d move to San Francisco to help build the sales team. Someone born in Massachusetts, schooled in Williamstown, who’d spent three years in downtown Boston and refused to live in New York, should have hesitated. I said yes without thinking. Since then I’ve closed over a million dollars of revenue, moved into management, and learned more about myself than in any job before it.
And now I’m doing it again. Later this year I’m moving to New York – the city I swore I’d never live in – to help build the sales team at another AI-native startup. Same milk crate, different corner. The imposter syndrome has already started up, which I’ve learned to read as a sign that the decision is the right size.
Williams prepared me for this in ways the career center never advertised. It taught me to follow what I was curious about instead of what was prescribed, and the job rewards that daily. It taught me autonomy: nobody checked whether I’d done the work, and nobody checks now either. It made me tough. Four years of getting pinned on a wrestling mat and playing D3 football taught me more about failure and coachability than any sales book. And it taught me, in the Fenway sense, to work for myself. Sales is entrepreneurship with a safety net. Your book of business is your business.
Sales isn’t what I thought it was. It isn’t pressuring people or persuading them. It’s asking good questions, hearing the answer, and creating a win for someone on the other side of the table. That turns out to be a very Williams thing to do for a living.
Neema Zarrabian ’21 is Senior Sales Manager at Unify, an AI-native go-to-market platform in San Francisco, where he joined as a founding account executive and now leads the growth sales team; he is relocating to New York later this year to join another early-stage AI company. A Psychology major at Williams, he writes about breaking into sales, cold outbound, and coaching reps, and can be found on LinkedIn.
Featured Post
October 26th, 2026
A Very Williams Thing to Do for a Living
I made $16 on my first day in sales. $10.25 after the train.
I was standing on a milk crate outside Fenway Park yelling “programs, get your programs here” for three hours in the sun. I lost my voice. A scalper told me the corner of Lansdowne had been his for ten years and I had no business being there. I thought about quitting.
Instead, on my day off, I went back and watched the best seller on the crew. He didn’t yell. He didn’t stand on a crate. He walked up to families in a calm voice and asked if they wanted a souvenir. The kids would look up at their parents, and any parent knows what happens next. He didn’t have the most transactions – he had the biggest ones. So I copied him. By the end of the summer I was a regular top-three seller, and I’d figured out that I loved sales because of the strategy and care that goes into it, not the yelling.
Nobody at Williams told me that was a career. When I walked into the career center as a psychology major, the menu was consulting, banking, or grad school. I didn’t want crazy hours. The most useful thing I found in that building was an email template buried in the alumni database with the subject line “Williams student seeking advice.” I sent a lot of those.
I fumbled my first three SDR interviews. On the mock cold call I pitched the product instead of the pain. For the mock email I googled “cold email tips” and wrote something so full of jargon that when I reread it months later it didn’t make sense. In the manager interview I talked the whole time about how great I’d be. After each rejection I asked for feedback, actually implemented it, and started preparing the way I’d been taught to prepare for a tutorial: two hours on the company, the interviewer, and the reps who already had the job. I got offers from three of my next five.
I was still scared. I had a psychology degree and no “real” experience. I was deathly afraid of cold calling for my first few weeks. The imposter syndrome didn’t leave when the results showed up. I hit 325% of quota my first month and set the team record for qualified leads in month two, and there were still weeks I felt like I was dialing into a black hole. When I got promoted to AE I was 3-14 on deals six months in. The reps who make it aren’t the ones who never feel doubt. They’re the ones who feel it and show up anyway.
What got me through was people. A Williams alum told me to read Fanatical Prospecting before day one. A seller named Jeff, whose “authentic selling” ideas turned my 3-14 into 14-3. Brian, my manager at Brazen, who answered every dumb question. Engineers who explained our product to me four different ways until I could explain it to a customer. My standing advice to anyone joining a startup is to get to know each person on the team individually before you sign, because you’re about to spend more waking hours with them than with anyone else in your life.
A couple of years ago, on vacation alone in Portugal, our founders asked if I’d move to San Francisco to help build the sales team. Someone born in Massachusetts, schooled in Williamstown, who’d spent three years in downtown Boston and refused to live in New York, should have hesitated. I said yes without thinking. Since then I’ve closed over a million dollars of revenue, moved into management, and learned more about myself than in any job before it.
And now I’m doing it again. Later this year I’m moving to New York – the city I swore I’d never live in – to help build the sales team at another AI-native startup. Same milk crate, different corner. The imposter syndrome has already started up, which I’ve learned to read as a sign that the decision is the right size.
Williams prepared me for this in ways the career center never advertised. It taught me to follow what I was curious about instead of what was prescribed, and the job rewards that daily. It taught me autonomy: nobody checked whether I’d done the work, and nobody checks now either. It made me tough. Four years of getting pinned on a wrestling mat and playing D3 football taught me more about failure and coachability than any sales book. And it taught me, in the Fenway sense, to work for myself. Sales is entrepreneurship with a safety net. Your book of business is your business.
Sales isn’t what I thought it was. It isn’t pressuring people or persuading them. It’s asking good questions, hearing the answer, and creating a win for someone on the other side of the table. That turns out to be a very Williams thing to do for a living.
Neema Zarrabian ’21 is Senior Sales Manager at Unify, an AI-native go-to-market platform in San Francisco, where he joined as a founding account executive and now leads the growth sales team; he is relocating to New York later this year to join another early-stage AI company. A Psychology major at Williams, he writes about breaking into sales, cold outbound, and coaching reps, and can be found on LinkedIn.